04-04-14, 09:56 PM
VNA, you ARE Alex Salmond, and I claim my £5! :lol
You seem to know more about what will happen than anyone else. Which is kind of par for the course, as the only ones who are certain they are right are the independance lobby. Oh, wait a minute, they include all the brightest economists and politicians in the world, right? I would suggest that no one really knows what the outcome of Scottish independance would be - what, for instance, will be the debt situation for Scotland after? For as many of one opinion on any aspect you can find, you will find as many opposite/contrary opinions. Why should anyone trust what YOU say on the subject? Are you not doing exactly the same as Salmond, just brow beating everyone into your way of thinking? You are exactly the kind of person who clouds the debate with rhetoric.
I don't claim to know an awful lot about the outcomes. But this is because we don't get informed by reasoned debate from qualified people. That's what this issue really needs before a single vote is taken in a referendum - or do you look down your nose on all those who aren't well informed (i.e. the majority) and say well, let me decide for you cos I know it all?
You seem to know more about what will happen than anyone else. Which is kind of par for the course, as the only ones who are certain they are right are the independance lobby. Oh, wait a minute, they include all the brightest economists and politicians in the world, right? I would suggest that no one really knows what the outcome of Scottish independance would be - what, for instance, will be the debt situation for Scotland after? For as many of one opinion on any aspect you can find, you will find as many opposite/contrary opinions. Why should anyone trust what YOU say on the subject? Are you not doing exactly the same as Salmond, just brow beating everyone into your way of thinking? You are exactly the kind of person who clouds the debate with rhetoric.
I don't claim to know an awful lot about the outcomes. But this is because we don't get informed by reasoned debate from qualified people. That's what this issue really needs before a single vote is taken in a referendum - or do you look down your nose on all those who aren't well informed (i.e. the majority) and say well, let me decide for you cos I know it all?