FZ1 Fazer Screen - Givi Touring screen??

[flesh]

I used to have a Yamaha Touring screen on my previous Gen 2 which I found was "ok" but loads of wind noise and buffeting on my lid. Much better than the standard though.
Looking for any alternatives and have seen the Givi and Puig touring screens. The Givi, whilst looking a  bit ugly, looks the most practical Anyone tried either of these?