I found that chainsaw oil is a bit thick and sticky for a scottoiler. I've used engine oil in them for years with no drama. I even ran a 2mm drill bit down the brass spigot to increase the flow slightly. Scottoil is a bit thin and light for my liking, A good downpour if rain washes it off! :rolleyes
Stop polishing it and ride the bloody thing!!
Lawrence, if you live anywhere near lincoln Ive got about a gallon of lube oil as used on powder coating conveyor track chains. Its too light to paint on a chain without flinging off over your back tyre but I think it is light enough to be applied by a scottoiler in its small amounts.
I use engine oil in my scotoiler, the only thing I find is you need to adjust the flow rate to suit the different.
If you worried about falling off your bike, you'd never get on.
If it's water soluble surely it's going to wash straight off the chain in the peeing rain? That's completely the opposite of what it's supposed to do...
The idea is to keep the chain moist and 'cool' and yes water will eventually wash it all off, but if the oiler is working correctly it will keep oiling the chain faster than the water will wash it off. I should have have made it clearer when washed with water the sticky residue needs a bit more effort to shift it and this stays on the chain for longer. I have noticed that when spilt it can be washed clean easily with water. Unlike ordinary oil it does not stick as well to tyres, thankfully.
The biggest killer of a chain is being run dry.