What didn't you like about the one you are selling? Sorry for the questions, but I will be looking to change my screen at some point.
I am 6.2 and the wind was hitting my helmet vents which caused some noise. THe wind protection was excellent with wind clearing shoulders and only hitting the helmet. The taller you are the harder it's on bike as far as elements protection is concerned.
I also considered rifle screen but they are much less sturdy than national ones with plastic being thinner and my concern was screen flexing under wind pressure.
Buying screen is more hit and miss as there are so many factors. Some peeps tolerate wind noise others find it disturbing etc If you have quiet helmet that might not be an issue. Mine is 8 year old so not the quietest at all
Paul