Fazer Owners Club - Unofficial

Bikes, Hints'n'Tips => Fazer 1000/FZ1 corner => Topic started by: richiomtt on 13 October 2012, 06:59:59 pm

Title: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 13 October 2012, 06:59:59 pm
Hi all,


New to the forum but been reading for a while and impressed with the knowledge out there.


So having studies the forum for a while, I've made several mods so far - jack-up kit, braided lines, Ivans soon.... Was going to do an R6 shock upgrade but read about the BMW S1000RR conversion and one was on ebay for £80, so bought that.


All fitted OK after drilling washers etc., but what I was surprised about was that I couldn't get the appropriate sag...too saggy even with the preload wound right up. I measured 20-25mm of unladen sag with that increasing to about 45mm with me sitting on it. Not good. That's with the STD dog bones as I like it a bit higher. I took off the shorter dog bones as it was so high with the BMW shock that the rear wheel touched the ground with the centrestand down!


What's confusing me is that on this and other forums the BMW spring is supposed to be firmer than the Yamaha one, but I managed to get the STD shock to the right pre-load no bother. So that would indicate that the BMW spring is actually softer??


Took it for a spin and it felt so much better than STD, especially the damping. Any thoughts appreciated. Thinking of getting an uprated (BMW) spring from Ktech for £85 fitted.


I'm around 14stone in all my gear.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: devilsyam on 13 October 2012, 07:40:38 pm
i think you will find that the yank did a lot of changes on the spring settling on a honda item

yes the shock is cheaper but not the same like for like v a r6 unit

add the extra cost on springs seems a odd choice

i looked into it and followed the posts as im all up for new idea's but diddnt see a bolt on solution

try finding a spring s/h om ebay to keep ya cost down
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 13 October 2012, 08:01:01 pm
Thanks for the comments. Yes, read through all the American stuff. The bloke that fitted his was a big fella (16St/225 lbs)and that's why he needed the bigger spring. I was surprised that I couldn't get the sag sorted when it's supposed to have a stiffer spring than the fazer. That was the confusing thing...


It is a high quality item though and already feels much better than the STD shock.


I read I can fit a CBR1000RR 04/05 spring straight on, but I can't find any of them for sale (at decent money). Might ride it for now and upgrade to a better spring later. Even with a Ktech spring, it will come in at £165 which is pretty good I think.


If it all goes wrong, I can always buy an R6 one one of yours...


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Jinx46 on 13 October 2012, 10:58:10 pm
Have a look at this post that i put up http://foc-u.co.uk/index.php/topic,4041.0.html (http://foc-u.co.uk/index.php/topic,4041.0.html)
 
I've had no problems since fitting this shock.The bike handles great.No need to change the spring.
Fit your shock with some dogbones from a '99 gsxr 750 and see for yourself.  :)
 
 
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 14 October 2012, 08:12:48 am
Thanks Jinx,


Had seen your post. In fact, that's what persuaded me try it :)


There's no question that the sag* is wrong though, but I agree it feels SO much better than the original shock. I went down my fave bumpy back road and it was so compliant and smooth. A world of difference. But I think it could be better if I got the right spring to get the sag as it should be. Just me probably being over the top to get it exactly right.


*Have you measured the rear sag on your Fazer? That might help me understand more.


Cheers
Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: t140 on 15 October 2012, 12:04:32 pm
fitted one of these about 2 months ago, no problems with spring rate and a big improvement in damping compared to the origonal
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 15 October 2012, 04:21:50 pm
Cheers for the comments. I agree and having ridden it this morning to work on 20 miles of back roads, I have to say it's transformed the bike. If I hadn't have measured the sag, I wouldn't be complaining..perhaps I'm being too fussy, but felt that it could be even better with a stiffer spring. Then again, that would probably overwhelm the standard front forks!!


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Jinx46 on 17 October 2012, 09:16:53 pm
Hi Rich,
 
Have i measured the sag on my Fazer?
No. Couldn't be arsed with all that.  :lol
 
I used a set up i found here:-ttp://www.sportrider.com/suspension_settings/suspension/146_suggested_suspension_settings/viewall.html#ixzz1vkaD3BNK (http://www.sportrider.com/suspension_settings/suspension/146_suggested_suspension_settings/viewall.html#ixzz1vkaD3BNK)
which is for the s1000rr.
I then used this as a start point and tweaked it from there.
The ride is really good,even with some weight in the top box and panniers  :)
 
Cheers
 
Tony
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: t140 on 18 October 2012, 10:53:33 am
I checked the settings in the bmw handbook, via google
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 18 October 2012, 06:34:46 pm
Thanks both,


The bmw is a full 25kg lighter than the Fazer though, hence settings for that bike won't necessarily work with the Fazer. I think that's why the static sag's too much as standard when the shock goes on the Fazer.


No problem though..if you're happy, you're happy.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Minty on 31 December 2012, 01:07:45 pm
Anyone got any thoughts fitting this shock with jack up dog bones on? do you think the longer dog bones/height will be any different to a standard height setup?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 31 December 2012, 03:53:12 pm
No, with the shorter dog bones (jack up kit) it won't fit. I've tried but the back wheel is on the ground with the centre stand! It's because the shock is a different size. If you put the standard dog bones on it will be about 20 to 25mm higher than stock. Works for me. I'm just about to get mine resprung at ktech with a stiffer spring and will report back.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: allanmac on 31 December 2012, 08:09:01 pm
Read a lot about this on the american forums definately the spring rate thats wrong for the fazer I think it was a fireblade spring they were fitting to replace the bm one.
Cheers Allan
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: devilsyam on 31 December 2012, 11:50:41 pm
Quote
No, with the shorter dog bones (jack up kit) it won't fit
Quote

+1 for the r6 shock then :rollin

streach wrote on usa site
Quote
If you are over 200 lbs, you may want to try the CBR1000RR spring. It worked well for me.
Quote

shock for donor spring looks like this

([url]http://i.ebayimg.com/t/2007-07-HONDA-CBR1000RR-rear-shock-linkages-100733-/20/[/url]!BoElbOQ!2k~$(KGrHqMH-DUEtt,eu6k4BLmDN+80f!~~_3.JPG)
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 02 January 2013, 12:44:12 pm
I have bought one of the BMW shocks too, to note from my internet research - there are 2 different sizes, the 2010 & 2011 ones with the gold bottom clevis will jack up a Fazer with standard dog bones, by an inch, but a shock from a 2012 BMW won't.
I am getting mine drilled by a mate at work, but what else do I need in temrs of washers to bolt this straight in, I was hoping to gather the materials and get it done this weekend.
I had a right result, £65 delivered and no need to change dog bones...!  :D
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 02 January 2013, 08:38:20 pm
Sounds good. All you need is 2 x 2-2.5mm washers araldited to the top shock and then it will go straight on. Use the same Fazer bolts.


I've just had a 95N/mm spring fitted on mine today (Standard BMW is 81N/mm and the Fazer is a soft 75N/mm). I've managed to get the static sag just right and although the roads were greasy it felt great. Even with the standard BMW spring it's way better than the Fazers. I weigh about 14 stone and tall.


The BMW shock is a quality piece of kit.


I found out about the 2012 being different too. Mine's  2011, hence nicely jacked-up just how I wanted it.


My mate popped out the top bush of the BMW shock and enlarged it on a lathe and it was much easier to do that he said.


Enjoy.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 03 January 2013, 09:05:22 am
Cheers Rich, are these washers just to pack it out sideways in the Fazer top mount? I need to order from ebay or similar, will 2 x 2.5mm ones go in or should I go for 2 x 2mm ?
 
Mate has taken the shock to work today, not sure if he will pop the bush out or just drill it in situ, if he succeeds and I can grab some washers, I'll hopefully chuck this in at the weekend.
 
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 03 January 2013, 04:34:16 pm
Yes, exactly that to pack the top mount. I think mine were 2mm each. The best thing to do is measure the Fazer one when it's off, and then get exactly the same. Quite sure mine were 2mm each side though. The good news is there's loads of ally in the top mount so you can glue then nice and flush and they'll never move again.


Let me know what you think of it. I love mine. Got 15-17mm of static sag and about 30-35mm of rider sag. If you haven't changed the spring and you weigh more than 13stone, I'd wind the preload all the way to max (all threads showing). I had position 8 on the high speed compression (large nut at the top) and 9 on the slow speed compression (inner screwdriver at the top) and 7 on the rebound (bottom).


Let us know how you get on.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 03 January 2013, 05:46:42 pm
Cheers bud, will do. Max preload for me then, LOL, I am about 15.5 stone without bike gear on. Popped to B&Q and they have bags of M12 washers for a few quid, double that of ebay but more readily available.
My mate who has it for drilling the bush works in an engineering works so hopefully he can grab me a couple anyway.
Did you glue them to the mount or the shock? I can't get my head around why they need glueing to be honest, but it might be clear when I get it apart.
I'm hoping for a decent dry day so I can take some time to clean all in and around the swingarm and back wheel while it's apart, BUT with it still being winter and the fact I will still use the bike, it might wait until spring for a proper clean, she's all covered in FS365 at the moment anyway.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Falcon 269 on 03 January 2013, 06:13:25 pm
The need to glue will become clear if you try to fit the shock and washers separately, mate ... ;) :) 
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 03 January 2013, 06:37:55 pm
Yup I certainly agree, unless you have 6 hands ;)


You need to glue the washers to the shock itself. Make sure they're set before you fit the shock as impatient me went for it straight the way and it was still a slippin and a slidin.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 04 January 2013, 10:59:35 am
Got it back from my mate last night and he had some washers in his kitchen drawer  :D
 
I figured it out as soon as I looked at it, reckoning it would be a swine otherwise.
 
Going to glue them up tonight and do the change tomorrow.
 
I don't have a tool for the preload -  reckon I'd be able to wind it up by hand off the bike or wait til I can grab a C spanner?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 04 January 2013, 02:05:49 pm
No chance by hand. Spray some WD40 on it and it will help. Best to do it in situ on the bike. If you're careful a large blunt screwdriver and hammer :eek  That's what I did in the end as couldn't get my c spanner in the right position
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 07 January 2013, 09:29:34 am
LOL, I did try by hand aswell, but NO, I'm not He-Man so failed.  :lol
 
Bit of a pain as I only thought the top mount needed drilling out, had to take it to a bike shop to have the lower one drilled and a new bolt sorted for it as the Yammy one was about 1/4" too short to support it.
 
All on and done though now, just needs setting up, preload is about half way and there is a bit too much sag, but it now feels a lot better damped, so I think it will be nice once I can wind it up.
Front end is also dropped about 10mm so I will level it back out to normal once I've jacked up the preload some more.
 
I think it will turn out to be a top mod for the money.  :D
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 07 January 2013, 11:03:09 am
Yep top and bottom need to be drilled but glad you got it on. My forks are also up 10 mm through the yokes and it's also jacked up at the rear (because of the BMW shock). It turns great now and no dog dragging it's bum feel. Also super stable... Enjoy.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 07 January 2013, 12:21:06 pm
Yeah far better, can't wait to get it set up properly. Looks loads better too!
 
Very hard on the high speed damping, I set them both to 6, gonna set the spring and set it all properly at the weekend, maybe one lunchtime if I get chance.
 
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 07 January 2013, 12:28:30 pm
pic
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 07 January 2013, 12:47:55 pm
 :)


Did you notice how light it was versus the original rubbish? It's a quality item and I keep thinking that's it's meant to help deal with 180BHP, so should be more than up to the job.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 07 January 2013, 03:56:26 pm
Yeah, I did actually, nearly dropped the original one as I cupped my hand under it.
 
I like the fact the BMW one has the rod shrouded too, so it's protected.
 
Bonus, like the R6 one, having high & low speed adjustment. I probably won't bother going for the Honda spring, I've bust my bike budget for the moment now, with new tyres and this shock, plus the chain is looking tired so that is gonna need doing soon.
 
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 08 January 2013, 11:46:47 am
Rich, can you do me a favour next time you are doing something to the bike?
Can you pop out the bolt that clamps the top spring adjuster, like a tit I left mine loose and it's fallen out somewhere outside the house!
 
 :rolleyes
 
Will try and find it but would be great if you could size it up for me please fella...
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 08 January 2013, 07:47:43 pm
Just to be clear, do you mean the little torx bolt that clamps the pre-load spring?


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 09 January 2013, 12:02:06 pm
yeah that's it mate..!
 
I tried a BMW fiche for the dimensions but it's not featured.... bloody inefficient krauts  :lol
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 09 January 2013, 02:54:45 pm
I need to wind the bike up a bit more as I still have a lot of sag (only measured by eye as yet) but the back wheel is very nearly on the floor while bike is on the centrestand. If I go more, I am worrying about the bike bloody rolling away while on the stand!
I may change the dogbones to give it a bit more clearance and make the front-end bias a little less extreme.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: richiomtt on 09 January 2013, 03:30:45 pm
My back wheel is very close the the ground too with the centrestand - don't worry about it. It rides just great and i can still spin the wheel to lube the chain no problem.


I'm not sure it's going to help you if I remove the pre-load screw and measure it. I won't be able to tell you the pitch and you can work our the length dead easy from the hole. This will be a £2 part at most, so I'd risk a small selection from a bolt manufacturer. It will be standard vehicle thread anyway.


Rich
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JayB on 09 January 2013, 04:11:05 pm
Just the diameter would help mate, but I will have a look at home and see if it fell out while I was working. I have a patch of concrete out the back I work on.
 
Hopefully once I wind it up a bit more as required, it won't deck out the tyre totally.
 
It is worth it, rides so much better, can't wait til the weekend to do my favourite 60 mile loop!   :)
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 07 March 2014, 08:44:16 pm
Just to add to this thread about the S1000rr Shock.
I finished fitting the 2012/13 S1000rr shock today and with the settings set to BMW normal number 4 Rebound number 4 low speed compression and number 4  high speed compression. I took it for a spin, what a difference no more wallowing  :) Must play around some more with the settings, but they are very good at BMW normal settings.
Measurements from Eye to Eye
Standard Fazer 100 shock is 305 mm
The  2012/13 s1000rr shock is 309mm It is easy to tell the difference between the two S1000rr shocks as the fork on the bottom of the 2013/13 shock is silver coloured and the older 2009/10 is bronze coloured like the top. See picture of visual difference in 2010/11 and 2012/13 shocks. The 2012/13 has improved damping control and slightly different standard setting to the 2011/12 shock

You will need the following for fitting:
A 12mm bit
Two 2.65mm thick washers 25mm outside diameter and 12mm diameter centre hole. I made them up as most standard are 2.5mm
A 12mm bolt with the shoulder 41.5mm long.
I used and old shoulder bolt from the top of the 600 shock, ground it to take the shoulder back to 41.5mm, re tapped it to take the standard M10 nut & washer and cut it to clear the dog bones. Original bolt was the correct length but shoulder was to short. The fork of the s1000rr Shock is 2mm wider overall. Using the original bolt was not an option.

Greased up all the linkages and put it back together.

As with previous posts the max preload was giving me 20mm static sag. I measured the thread space at the top of the shock and there is 12mm of  space with the shock on max preload. I will make up a 7 to 10 mm spacer to fit under the spring to allow me add more preload and see how it goes from there. It feels fine at the moment as the laden sag is less than the sag at max preload of the original shock.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 16 March 2014, 09:22:19 pm
Went for a run with my son on the back today we are both about 13.5stone weight in full bike gear and the shock was outstanding. The spring was a little soft over some exceptionally bad roads (we were watching the West Cork Rally) and some slightly spirited riding but it never bottomed out. Had some fun with a few "wanna be rally car drivers" :rolleyes on the way to some stages. :lol.  A 2012/13 S1000rr shock is definitely a worthwhile investment if you can get it for the right money. :) It will be fine with my wife on the back as she is only 9 stone in full bike gear. Next stop the North West 200 with a few friends to really test it out. :)
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: bludclot on 26 March 2014, 07:59:39 pm



zero miles, £40 including postage. i couldn't resist:


(http://portchesterpropertymaintenance.co.uk/images/fazer/rrshock.jpg)


going to fit this in conjunction with a forks strip and overhaul. i'll post the results once done. i do my own mehcanical work but know very little about suspension so will be subjective. current shock is the standard fzs unit that i had re-built around 5k miles ago.



Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: shrekster on 26 March 2014, 08:54:49 pm
I bid on the same shock from this seller, he listed that he had 2 shocks for sale by mistake. He only had the one, bummer! I already have a BMW shock with a 550lb spring on my Fazer, I've only done a few short runs and the rear end feels brilliant.
Jim.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 26 March 2014, 09:46:39 pm
Check the bottom adjuster on the shock, its a pain to get to from the exhaust side of the bike when fitted. I had to rotate the shock bottom 180 degrees so it was on the chain side.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 26 March 2014, 11:35:46 pm


zero miles, £40 including postage. i couldn't resist:


going to fit this in conjunction with a forks strip and overhaul. i'll post the results once done. i do my own mehcanical work but know very little about suspension so will be subjective. current shock is the standard fzs unit that i had re-built around 5k miles ago.

Set it as standard first all the damping settings at 4, but wind the preload up full.  :)
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: bludclot on 08 May 2014, 10:05:41 am



fitted this and rode the bike yesterday. ride is definitely improved.


unfazed is absolutely correct - the bottom bolt needs to be 41.5mm shouldered, i have the standard bolt in there but this means that the nut end of the shoulder is only within the shock fork by 2mm (or so) of the 6mm available. an option i did consider was taking 1mm off each of the shock fork legs - seeing as the original shock fork legs are 5mm it should be ok - but i would rather fit a longer shouldered bolt. so, can anyone supply me or point me towards such a bolt please?


i did not find it necessary to glue washers to the top of the shock for fitting. it was straight forward to slide the mounting bolt through the frame then through the first washer then through the shock then slide the second washer into the gap then tap the bolt home, easy.


my other issue is at the top of the shock however. the original shock when bolted in just at the top had no real lateral movement. the bmw shock moved all over the place however, not encouraging at all. the shoulder of the bolt was a snug fit into the drilled bushes so i figure the issue is elsewhere, most likely with the washers.


so to conclude, good upgrade but not a straight forward bolt in job as has been suggested in the past.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 08 May 2014, 01:09:27 pm
Odd, mine went straight in.  The only thing I did was make some new bushes for the top, I didn't fancy washers so removed the original bushes and made new ones.  (and put a stronger spring on). The bottom bolt went through fine, like standard.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 08 May 2014, 05:40:43 pm
Odd, mine went straight in.  The only thing I did was make some new bushes for the top, I didn't fancy washers so removed the original bushes and made new ones.  (and put a stronger spring on). The bottom bolt went through fine, like standard.
Was yours the 2010/2011?

The spring on the 2012/2013 is a heaver rated spring and should suit anybody up to about 150kg.

Combined weight of my wife and I is 140Kg and it handles great with the two of us on it.

The top of mine was sloppy loose until I torqued up the bolt/nut properly.

I would not advise touching the fork, but get a top shock bolt from a breaker and cut it down to fit. The ones from the 600 and 1000 are the same so plenty of them out there.

Collected the 10mm spacer for the spring today and will fit it over the weekend to allow me play with the static sag.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 08 May 2014, 07:09:31 pm
2013. The spring was stiffer than the std fazer one but not by much.  I do a lot of two up riding so put a stronger one on
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 08 May 2014, 07:59:47 pm
2013. The spring was stiffer than the std fazer one but not by much.  I do a lot of two up riding so put a stronger one on

Any idea what the spring rate of the spring you put in is? I have an old Fireblade shock in the garage and the spring is the same size but I must check the spring rate of it as I cannot remember which year Fireblade it was taken from.
Out of curiosity any idea of the combined weight of both of you, I was out with my eldest son on the back and our combined weight was about 170Kg and the spring felt a bit soft only on really bumpy roads. If I go touring on it this year I might need to upgrade the spring if increasing the static sag does not help.

I should be able to adjust the static sag more when I fit the 10mm spacer to the bottom spring seat..
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 08 May 2014, 08:42:40 pm
I don't unfortunately, we had a few springs and this one was the same thickness as the BMW spring but had less coils hence stiffer (and felt stiffer when fitted).  I think its off a ZX10R.  Combined weight probably around 170/180 + top box and contents)
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JoeRock on 09 May 2014, 09:11:37 am
2013. The spring was stiffer than the std fazer one but not by much.  I do a lot of two up riding so put a stronger one on

Any idea what the spring rate of the spring you put in is? I have an old Fireblade shock in the garage and the spring is the same size but I must check the spring rate of it as I cannot remember which year Fireblade it was taken from.
Out of curiosity any idea of the combined weight of both of you, I was out with my eldest son on the back and our combined weight was about 170Kg and the spring felt a bit soft only on really bumpy roads. If I go touring on it this year I might need to upgrade the spring if increasing the static sag does not help.

I should be able to adjust the static sag more when I fit the 10mm spacer to the bottom spring seat..


That's really not the way to do it mate - for linear springs increasing the static sag isn't going to make a blind bit of difference (it'll just make the ride height about right), it's just where the suspension sits in its stroke. Practically all it means is you'll have a lot less suspension travel to cope with any big bumps you hit, and if the spring is that soft it'll bottom out!
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 09 May 2014, 07:25:51 pm
Joe

Appreciate the comment, but I am aware that changing the static sag cannot change the spring rate, but if you read what I said "If increasing the static sag does not help."  and since it never bottomed out with the combined weight of 170Kg, I was more concerned about the drop in ride height.. It felt softer than I liked which is why I will consider changing the spring. The spacer I had made was to allow me play around with the ride height since the standard shock set up will not allow me go lower than 20mm static sag and I would like to try it at 10mm.

The reason I asked the question about the Spring rate of the spring North Westerner used is that I have 2 springs which are the same dimensions as the S1000rr one, 14.7Kg 600 fazer and a 12Kg RR Fireblade. Just checked the Ktech site and they list all RR Fireblades from 2004 to 2013 at 12Kg and since it came off a RR Fireblade solves the problem not being able to  remember which year it was.
The 2012/2013 S1000rr is as far as I can make out is about 9Kg and 12Kg is to big a step since it is pretty good as it is.

Unfortunately K Tech do not cover the later S1000rr or ZX10 on their site.


When I fitted the Hagon Shock to the 600 it was 14.6Kg and it felt a bit on the soft side 2 up and I changed it to a 16KG one which was perfect. Based on this, ideally I would like to try a 10.5 Kg spring first before going higher.





Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: nsr500v4 on 13 May 2014, 08:47:34 pm
Look what the postie brought me today  :D


Shock
Shock


 All we need is some posts on how everyone sets their shock up with rider weights, spring preload etc etc to give everyone the benefit of the knowledge built over over the months of set ups
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: pitternator on 19 May 2014, 12:24:40 pm
I chuckle a bit when folk call the OE shock rubbish. It isn't , its just got way too weak a spring . Ktech  and others did a rebuild which actually worked quite  well 10 yrs back. The full monty K tech is as good as anything out there.... they claim up to ohlins standard..... The OE shock in the picture is maybe 10 to 12 yrs old, never cleaned, never looked after .  Hope you look after the RR one.
Incidentally , just why are so many RR shock about ?...is it leftovers from racers  fitting decent stuff like K tech shocks !   :lol

But if its cheap and you like it , go ahead. Personally the weakness in all this fitting of shocks from other bikes is setting yer bikes up, and hoping you have the right spring to get the sag right. You have to get the sag right before you even consider damping adjustments. I do applaud ingenuity and perseverance. But do remember if you have  a knackered shock on yer bike..ANYTHING will feel marvellous. But it could still be far from ideal. Ask me how I know !
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 19 May 2014, 06:03:34 pm
I never considered the OEM shock rubbish, I thought it was a pretty good shock, but as you say the spring was way to soft. However when I saw a  zero miles 2012 S1000rr for sale in the USA for $120 including postage, I bought it. A new spring was £105 including postage in the UK. I decided to try the S1000rr option.
The advantage of that shock is that is raises the rear 10mm without any modification to the dog bones and improves the turn in on the fazer.
Since it is made by Sachs is is also a good quality item and was much more cost effective than buying a new spring or shock. :)



Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 20 May 2014, 04:43:25 pm
Is that the ktech rebuild which replaced the adjusters, shim stack, shock body etc?  I doubt they can offer anything in the same price bracket really.


Racers don't replace their shocks with a £300 "Sport" shocks they get the big ones ~£1000 which isn't really a good comparison.  For less that £100 you can have a modern design shock with hardly any miles on it and a spring suited to your weight. then you can play with the settings which some folk enjoy doing.



Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JoeRock on 23 May 2014, 02:09:04 am
Would someone with one of these be kind enough to let me know a few measurements?


I need the length of the shock, as close as possible, from centre to centre mounting holes
Also the weight of the spring on there as stock
and the measurements accross the mount at the top, and inside the bottom?

Basically, I'm considering fitting one to my zx9r if it'll fit and its about right!
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 23 May 2014, 08:45:37 am
http://foc-u.co.uk/index.php/topic,4976.msg132497.html#msg132497 (http://foc-u.co.uk/index.php/topic,4976.msg132497.html#msg132497)

I can check the rest tonight as I have one in the garage
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 24 May 2014, 01:53:39 pm
Finally got around to fitting the spacer to the S1000RR shock to enable me to set the static sag to my liking.
See picture it fits nicely

Joe Rock I have 2 shocks and both are slightly different top and bottom one is .15 more and the other is .15 less then the 29.5mm as the average of both measurements

Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JoeRock on 24 May 2014, 05:32:58 pm
Cheers for that Unfazed!


Hadn't realised the info was on there already!  :o


Unfortunately it's way to short for mine, Zx9 is about 337mm so something with a 20mm drop would have to be modded, which would probably make it as expensive again!
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: bludclot on 11 June 2014, 06:22:03 pm



i had these made up from stainless steel at my local machine shop:


(http://portchesterpropertymaintenance.co.uk/images/fazer/kit1.jpg)


here's the longer shoulder of the bottom bolt and the standard bolt against the bmw shock:


(http://portchesterpropertymaintenance.co.uk/images/fazer/kit2.jpg)


many thanks to unfazed for his measurements, spot on.


i had two sets made so one is spare. it owes me 15 so if anyone wants it..... my machine shop man said that he can make more sets if required.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Paolo_69 on 31 August 2014, 10:41:12 am
Hello there from Italy  8)
after reading about this mod, I have replaced my original shock with a S1000RR '12 with 4000 km.
The shock works very good (everything works better than the original), the only proble is that with the shock fully preloaded I have a statit sag of 27 mm (against a reccomended 10-15) and a rider sag of 55 (against a reccomended 30-40). My weight is 90 kg
This make me thinking that the spring rigidity is correct, but the spring is too short, it'd be 10-15 mm longer.
What you think? Could I resolv with a 10-15 mm spacer under the spring?


ps sorry for my bad english...
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: JoeRock on 01 September 2014, 07:45:59 pm
Hello there from Italy  8)
after reading about this mod, I have replaced my original shock with a S1000RR '12 with 4000 km.
The shock works very good (everything works better than the original), the only proble is that with the shock fully preloaded I have a statit sag of 27 mm (against a reccomended 10-15) and a rider sag of 55 (against a reccomended 30-40). My weight is 90 kg
This make me thinking that the spring rigidity is correct, but the spring is too short, it'd be 10-15 mm longer.
What you think? Could I resolv with a 10-15 mm spacer under the spring?


ps sorry for my bad english...

You need a stiffer spring mate, by quite some way too!
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 08 September 2014, 09:28:03 pm
Hello there from Italy  8)
after reading about this mod, I have replaced my original shock with a S1000RR '12 with 4000 km.
The shock works very good (everything works better than the original), the only proble is that with the shock fully preloaded I have a statit sag of 27 mm (against a reccomended 10-15) and a rider sag of 55 (against a reccomended 30-40). My weight is 90 kg
This make me thinking that the spring rigidity is correct, but the spring is too short, it'd be 10-15 mm longer.
What you think? Could I resolv with a 10-15 mm spacer under the spring?


ps sorry for my bad english...

Does your shock have the silver or bronze coloured shock fork. The silver one allow adjustement of the sag to 20mm the bronze one only allow adjustement of the sag to 27mm.

I did fit a 10 mm spacer to my silver forked one to allow more adjustment, but found that adjusting the sag to 15mm made it hop over bumps and set it back to 20mm. I weigh about 87Kg.

Read back through my posts

Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 16 September 2014, 03:35:24 pm
Odd, mine went straight in.  The only thing I did was make some new bushes for the top, I didn't fancy washers so removed the original bushes and made new ones.  (and put a stronger spring on). The bottom bolt went through fine, like standard.

Do you have the dimensions and/or a picture of the one you made up? I was thinking of doing the same.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 16 September 2014, 03:42:59 pm
No pics I'm afraid.  It was simply a "hat" type spacer.  Basically measure the std bush but with a 2mm thick rim.  This is in two parts (both identical), one for each side.  I think the standard one is also in two parts.


Thats about all I remember really...
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Paolo_69 on 29 October 2014, 11:22:36 am
Does your shock have the silver or bronze coloured shock fork. The silver one allow adjustement of the sag to 20mm the bronze one only allow adjustement of the sag to 27mm.

I did fit a 10 mm spacer to my silver forked one to allow more adjustment, but found that adjusting the sag to 15mm made it hop over bumps and set it back to 20mm. I weigh about 87Kg.

Read back through my posts


The shock is a 2012 with silver fork; at last I have used a spring from a R6 shock with a 10 mm spacer, and the shock works great with my weight (95 kg dressed). In this configuration I have obtained a static sag of 15 mm and a rider sag of 35, but I felt the bike too hard; actually I have reduced the preload of 6 mm, with a rider sag of 41 mm, and I feel much more confidence and comfort.
The rebound damping is set to 5, I switch the LS compression damping between 2 and 3 depending on the road; the HS compression damping is 4 as standard, I have no idea how to set this one
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 19 June 2019, 07:34:01 pm
So wich one should I choose? The one with the silver fork or the bronze fork?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: PieEater on 19 June 2019, 09:21:02 pm
Sheesh in 4 and a half years I'd be surprised if you could tell the difference  :eek
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: coffee on 19 June 2019, 11:31:36 pm
Does your shock have the silver or bronze coloured shock fork. The silver one allow adjustement of the sag to 20mm the bronze one only allow adjustement of the sag to 27mm.

I did fit a 10 mm spacer to my silver forked one to allow more adjustment, but found that adjusting the sag to 15mm made it hop over bumps and set it back to 20mm. I weigh about 87Kg.

Read back through my posts


The shock is a 2012 with silver fork; at last I have used a spring from a R6 shock with a 10 mm spacer, and the shock works great with my weight (95 kg dressed). In this configuration I have obtained a static sag of 15 mm and a rider sag of 35, but I felt the bike too hard; actually I have reduced the preload of 6 mm, with a rider sag of 41 mm, and I feel much more confidence and comfort.
The rebound damping is set to 5, I switch the LS compression damping between 2 and 3 depending on the road; the HS compression damping is 4 as standard, I have no idea how to set this one



my brain's just froze  :lol
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: Stinka on 24 July 2019, 01:59:46 pm
So wich one should I choose? The one with the silver fork or the bronze fork?


I’ve got the bronze one. It’s epic
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 23 November 2019, 05:41:55 pm
Anyone knows what bolt should i look for to reuse with the BMW shock?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 23 November 2019, 09:14:33 pm
A 12mm bolt with the shoulder 41.5mm long, you can cut it to clear the dog bones and leave a few mm more than the nut..Important bit is the 41.5mm shoulder
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 24 November 2019, 04:25:12 pm
OK, perfect, thanks very much.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 28 November 2019, 04:51:10 pm
A 12mm bolt with the shoulder 41.5mm long, you can cut it to clear the dog bones and leave a few mm more than the nut..Important bit is the 41.5mm shoulder


Any tip on how to adjust the shock? I am 100kg and riding solo. Any start point will help
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 28 November 2019, 04:55:37 pm
Is it the one with bronze bottom fork or the silver bottom fork?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: NorthWestern on 28 November 2019, 06:15:37 pm
Catalin, a new spring would be the first thing to get.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 30 November 2019, 08:00:12 pm
Is it the one with bronze bottom fork or the silver bottom fork?


Silver one, 2013 i think
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 30 November 2019, 08:00:55 pm
Catalin, a new spring would be the first thing to get.


A spring for the BMW shock?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 01 December 2019, 12:59:46 pm
Set the rear preload 15 to 20mm, be careful not to wind the adjuster off the threads as it will damage them.
Set all damping adjusters to 4.
I weigh 85kg and my wife about 55kg which is 40kg more than your weight and have toured with that setting. 

After 20000km I changed the damping to 5 all round and never had to touched the preload in that time.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 01 December 2019, 05:11:13 pm
Ok, thanks for the feedback, will be doing that soon it gets to me. Thank you
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 13 January 2020, 08:52:26 pm
Set the rear preload 15 to 20mm, be careful not to wind the adjuster off the threads as it will damage them.
Set all damping adjusters to 4.
I weigh 85kg and my wife about 55kg which is 40kg more than your weight and have toured with that setting. 

After 20000km I changed the damping to 5 all round and never had to touched the preload in that time.


I was lookin over your advices. Why didn't you use a 12 mm nut for the 12 mm bolt?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 13 January 2020, 09:57:44 pm
I didnt have a suitable  self locking nut available at the time.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 14 January 2020, 07:44:13 pm
OK, so i can use a 12mm nut. I was thinking that something is not fitting there, thats why you used a 10mm nut
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 14 January 2020, 10:10:49 pm
Yes, no issues with using a 12mm self locking nut.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: CatalinU on 16 January 2020, 11:19:15 am
What material did you use for those two shims? Shpould I do them 2,65 thick or 2.5 thick?
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: unfazed on 16 January 2020, 12:06:23 pm
They need to be 2.65mm thick otherwise you will ending up bending something or the shock will be loose.
I got a fellow to make them for me out of an Aluminium bar.
There is a fellow called Derek Pierce in the Yamaha FZS 1000 Fazer group on Facebook making the spacers.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: oldninjaron on 03 August 2020, 06:42:13 pm
Hi
Carried out this mod using early 2009 shock but instead of drilling both mounts to 12mm, I followed another method spotted elsewhere which retains 10mm bolts using custom bearing sleeves, OD 12mm ID 10MM, fitted to fazer mount points.  I fitted 110NM spring to shock, set Compression adjusters to BMW "Comfort" positions and Rebound to 7, so far.  At same time fitted r6 5EB forks, resprung also.  Bike handles great just harsh over sharp bumps.  Came back after latest run found what feels like top mount worn, lifted rear found a lot of play, I now have correct spacers for top mount to fit but it may well be BMW shock mount may be extremely worn - if necessary how do you remove the top bushes, any help would be much appreciated.
Title: Re: BMW S1000RR shock conversion question
Post by: kralik on 24 September 2020, 08:24:48 am
Set the rear preload 15 to 20mm, be careful not to wind the adjuster off the threads as it will damage them.
Set all damping adjusters to 4.
I weigh 85kg and my wife about 55kg which is 40kg more than your weight and have toured with that setting. 

After 20000km I changed the damping to 5 all round and never had to touched the preload in that time.
Hi,I just fitted s1000rr shock into my FZS and was looking for how to set it up properly.So, many thanks for your advices about setting up of damping.Just a question, the rear preload is for standard bmw spring, or is it with different spring?And the rear preload 15-20mm is from the top side right?
Anyway, I read some info, that the rear shocks use to have different length. For the earlier ones the lowering dog bone kit is needed and for the later ones it is not needed.How can I find out whether I need the lowering kit or whether I should stay with the standard dog bones, please?TIA